Medical alerts · Guide
Medical alerts when you have hearing loss: what to check before you buy
The short version
- Most medical alerts work by two-way voice: you press a button and talk with an agent.
- With hearing loss, the key question is where that voice comes out, and whether you can understand it.
- Test the speaker in your own home before the return window closes.
- Plan for the times your hearing aids are out, like at night and in the shower.
Why this matters
People with hearing loss may need a medical alert more, not less. A 2012 Johns Hopkins and National Institute on Aging study found that people aged 40 to 69 with mild hearing loss had nearly three times the odds of reporting a fall in the prior year.1 Yet the standard medical alert call is a conversation. ADT, for example, describes its devices as connecting to its monitoring center with built-in two-way voice.2 If you cannot make out what the agent says, the system works less well for you.
Six things to check
1. Where does the voice come from?
On some home systems, the button you wear has no speaker; you talk through the base station. ADT's fall detection pendant guide says the pendant "is not capable of two-way communication" and that you speak with the operator through the base station or mobile device.3 That means the base needs to be close to where you spend time, and loud enough to hear from the bathroom or bedroom. Ask each company: does the wearable itself have a speaker, or only the base?
2. Can you test it at home?
Hearing loss is personal, and no spec sheet tells you whether you will understand a voice through a small speaker in your own rooms. Before you buy, ask for the trial or return terms in writing. Once it arrives, run a test call from the room farthest from the base, with your hearing aids in and with them out.
3. What happens if you can't answer?
Know the company's rule for silence. ADT's pendant guide says that if you do not respond or speak to the operator after an alert, emergency help will be dispatched.3 Ask every company the same question, and ask whether the agent also calls a family member or caregiver. When you set up those contacts, make your first contact someone who lives or works close by and can get to you in minutes. In a New York City apartment building, that could be your doorman.
4. Will family get a text, not just a call?
Many companies offer caregiver apps or notifications. Features vary by company and plan, so ask specifically whether alerts reach family by text or app notification, which is easier for everyone than a phone call.
5. Does it work when your hearing aids are out?
Many people take hearing aids out to sleep and shower, the moments when bathroom falls and night-time trips happen. Ask whether the wearable can be worn in the shower. Lively, for instance, says its Mobile2 is water resistant and can be worn in the shower.4 If you choose fall detection, also check how it must be worn (see our fall detection guide).
6. Your backups
- Voice 911 remains the most reliable way to reach help. Text-to-911 works only where your local 911 center supports it; elsewhere you will get a bounce-back message.5
- If you use a TTY, call 911 directly in an emergency rather than going through 711 relay.6
- Smoke alarms are a separate problem. See our hearing loss and safety hub.
Questions to ask any medical alert company
| Question | Why it matters with hearing loss |
|---|---|
| Does the wearable have its own speaker? | Otherwise you must hear the base station from where you fell. |
| Can I adjust the speaker volume? | A volume you can hear in a quiet room may not carry across the house. |
| What is the trial or return period, in writing? | You need time to test calls in your own home. |
| What happens if I don't answer the agent? | You may not hear the agent's questions. |
| Can caregivers get text or app alerts? | Text is easier to share and harder to miss. |
| Who should be the first person they call? | Choose someone nearby who can reach you in minutes. In a New York City apartment building, that could be your doorman. |
| Can I wear it in the shower? | Hearing aids usually come out there. |
Hearing better helps with every one of these. If you are weighing hearing aids, The Hearing Edit compares over-the-counter and prescription options. We don't review hearing aids on this site.
Sources
- JAMA Internal Medicine (2012), Hearing Loss and Falls Among Older Adults in the United States
- ADT, ADT Medical Alert Systems: FAQs. Company statement
- ADT, Fall Detection Pendant User Guide (PDF). Company manual
- Lively, Fall Detection for Seniors. Company statement
- FCC, Text to 911: What You Need to Know
- FCC, 711 for TTY-Based Telecommunications Relay Service